Tag: Oxidation

  • Zinc has bigger game than you do

    Zinc has bigger game than you do

     

    Still struggling to pick out that one in a million Valentine’s Day gift? Worry no longer, because I have the perfect gift idea sure to make anyone melt. No – it’s not superhot plasma from your favorite star gone supernova (the Biebs?) – We’re talking zinc baby. Baby. Baby. Baby. Oh baby.

    Zinc coatings on steel to be exact, through the process of “hot dip” galvanization.  The hot dip part is literal – pieces of steel are dunked in a bath of molten zinc metal and when they are removed a thin layer of zinc is atomically attached to the surface of the steel. The “galvanized” part belies the true function of the coating, considering this word is derived from a certain Italian who took liberties with dead frogs.

    “Why bother?” Your significant other may ask.  “Here I had this nice piece of steel and now you’ve gone and hot dipped it. I think we’re at two different places in our relationship.” We’ve all been there.

    The role of the zinc is to protect the iron in iron alloys (most importantly steel) from rusting. Like a proverbial knight in shining (preferably hot dipped) armor, zinc prevents the steel from rusting by selflessly doing all the rusting itself. As I describe it, this is starting to sound a lot less romantic and more like zinc has wandered into the friend-zone. Poor zinc.

    If you read my last article, you know that natural corrosion resistance is rare among the elements, but ironically zinc protects steel by being less good at resisting the undesirable reactions with oxygen and water that cause the formation of rust on steel. A good analogy for this process is if both zinc and iron open lemonade stands on the same block and oxygen is the customer. Every time iron is trying to seal the deal zinc unleashes a humorous ad campaign and slashes their prices, so naturally oxygen buys lemonade from zinc instead. Now replace lemonade with electrons and you’ve got a half-decent understanding of how zinc does its job – as far as oxygen is concerned it came to this two bit lemonade town to buy lemonade from somebody (form an atomic bond), and zinc sure is looking pretty good right now. The only discrepancy with this analogy is that in the business world iron would have to resort to foul play and steal all of zinc’s lemons or deface their billboards or something. Probably shouldn’t write that on your next chemistry exam though. But don’t feel bad for zinc – the corrosion products of zinc with the environment (zinc oxide and zinc carbonate), actually prevent continued corrosion of the underlying zinc. This is called “passivation” which is the way that many other metals, like aluminum, avoid needing a hot dip.

    So we’ve covered the “from the heart” part of a good V-day gift, but a box of galvanized nails might not send the right message to the apple of your eye. The good news is hot-dip galvanized steel looks really cool. The next time you’re passing a guard rail, street light pole or the like, you might notice a kind of patchwork series of flecks on the surface of the steel. No, that’s not art deco, those are the macro-sized crystalline grains of zinc busy oxidizing away. You can see some of these flecks inside the heart at the beginning of this article. In fact, all metals crystallize in this way, but because of how the zinc coating is applied the crystals of zinc that form on the surface of the steel are able to grow very large. If you were to take a high powered microscope and have a look at the surface of un-galvanized steel you would see a very similar grain structure but about 1000 times smaller. A good example is shown below from the Flikr photostream by the department of engineering at the University of Cambridge –  I admit I am a little jealous at all the cool science photos they have. Do yourself a favor and check them out.  The grains in this image are about 30-50 micrometers, which is about half the width of a human hair.

    Normally the grain size in so called “engineering materials” like steel is intentionally kept very small because it improves strength. Zinc, whose only role is as a sacrificial coating, can flaunt its’ big ole’ grains. The only other example I can think of where crystal grains are visible like this is in polycrystalline silicon solar cells. The fact that all three of these materials have the same general appearance is not by chance, but more on that another time.

     

     

     

    If love is sacrifice, then zinc has got it down. I will close with a poem that you can use with your gift:

    Roses are red,

    Rust is red too,

    A coating of zinc,

    says I – LOVE – YOU

     

    And don’t I just.

     

    – Gordon

     

    Original image sources:

    hot dip galvanized

    grains of steel

     

  • Even though Kim Kardashian’s marriage didn’t last, her engagement ring will. Like forever.

    Even though Kim Kardashian’s marriage didn’t last, her engagement ring will. Like forever.

    I have a joke for you:

     

    How long does a two million dollar engagement ring buy you with everyone’s favorite (well, mine anyways) Kardashian sister?

     

    As Kris Humphries found out, about 72 days.

     

    Sorry Kris, but at least you should take some comfort in the fact that the ring you gave Kim will sit as shiny as it is right now until it’s ready to win hearts and headlines once again. At least the platinum band will anyways. What I’m referring to as the simply staggering resistance of Platinum to oxidation, more commonly known as rust or tarnish.  Platinum, along with gold and to a lesser extent silver are  the only metals on the periodic table that enjoy this distinction. As a logical consequence, these metals were some of the first discovered by ancient peoples because they would have quite literally been found lying on the ground, super shiny. In fact, gold was the first metal discovered ever and goes back as far as the entire history of… well as far back as recorded history itself! I like to imagine when cavemen discovered gold they tried to eat it before proposing to cave ladies with chunks of the stuff. Given that these un-reactive metals are now relatively commonplace, the idea of a metal that doesn’t rust may not seem that cool but trust me, it is.

     

    So why aren’t these magical metals applied to more commonplace items where rust is a concern? The obvious answer is their astronomical expense. Unfortunately the expense of platinum, gold and silver is not because they don’t rust but because they are super rare, representing some of the rarest elements found it the earths crust. Even if they were more common, each of these metals are extremely ductile and malleable allowing them to be easily fashioned through pulling and hammering into jewelry but preventing their use as structural metals. Gold’s softness is the origin of the quintessential gold rush miner biting into a dubious coin to ensure it’s authenticity. Thus even if you wanted to and were rich and crazy enough to do so, it would be unwise to make solid gold or platinum rims because they would buckle when popping over a curb.

     

    The diamonds in Kim’s ring are another story. Formed from carbon under extreme conditions of huge temperatures and pressures, diamonds are chemically identical to pencil lead but differ in the way the atoms are arranged. Instead of being soft enough to smear onto a sheet of paper when pressed by hand, diamonds are the hardest naturally occurring substance on earth. Ironically, according to calculations using thermodynamics, a discipline used to determine the equilibrium structure for a given set of conditions and composition, diamonds should not even exist outside of the extreme conditions in which they are formed! Instead, thermodynamics predicts that diamonds should deteriorate to graphite (pencil lead) at the temperatures and pressures found around Kim Kardashian’s hand. Then why don’t they?

     

    To answer that we can consider again our friends platinum and gold. It is not exactly correct to say that these metals can never oxidize, but more accurate to say that without a huge input of energy they never will. Meanwhile, metals like iron actually give off some energy when they rust. From the standpoint of iron, it is energetically favorable to rust than remain as elemental iron in the presence of oxygen. A good analogy to this kind of “favorable energetics” is a cart balanced at the top of a hill – the cart has potential energy that is converted to kinetic energy and then depleted  when it rolls down the hill. An unfavorable energy case would be a cart in a deep valley. Even though the cart could reach the top of the hill, someone would have to push it up there. Maybe you could get those cavemen to do it by feeding them gold. To transform diamonds into graphite and oxidize platinum will take energy. Lots of energy. So unless Kim visits the National Ignition Facility, an active volcano or these guys, her ring is staying put. Just maybe not on her finger.

    Image: Maggie Smith / FreeDigitalPhotos.net